What started as a candle-making hobby has grown into a shop filled with handmade goods, thoughtful gifts, and plenty of creativity.
For Natalie, owner of Wishing Well Candles & Gifts at Bricker Village, the business began with a simple goal: making candles she could enjoy burning in her own home. After experimenting with different ingredients and fragrances, she began selling her creations online, eventually expanding into other retail shops before opening a storefront of her own.
Today, visitors can find Natalie’s hand-poured candles alongside products from local makers, with something for just about everyone on their gift list.
A Little More About Natalie
Creativity has always been a big part of Natalie’s life. Originally from New York, she studied photography and printmaking, earning multiple bachelor’s degrees in the visual arts. Her photographs and paintings have been exhibited in galleries throughout New York, with several receiving awards.
That artistic background carries into Wishing Well, from the candles she makes to the way she arranges and selects merchandise for the shop.
Natalie also makes pottery and loves spending time with her two dogs, Wolfie and Theo. Nature is one of her biggest sources of inspiration for new fragrances, whether she’s hiking with her dogs or simply enjoying time outdoors.

What’s Behind the Name?
There’s a personal meaning behind Wishing Well Candles & Gifts.
The name comes from the sentiment “I wish you well,” reflecting Natalie’s original interest in creating candles with ingredients she felt comfortable using.
The name also has a literal connection to her candles. As the wax melts, the dried flowers she adds gradually sink toward the bottom of the jar, creating her own version of a wishing well.
A Closer Look at the Candles
Every Wishing Well candle is hand-poured right inside the Bricker Village shop, using ingredients sourced from across the United States.
Natalie uses soy wax made from non-GMO soybeans in Kentucky, cedarwood wicks from California, and glass jars manufactured in Ohio. She blends essential oils to create her fragrances and adds dried flowers, fruits, herbs, and spices for decorative touches without using artificial dyes.
A large batch takes approximately 48 hours from start to finish. After preparing the jars and wicks, Natalie melts and pours the wax in batches before adding the finishing touches. The candles then need time to cure before they’re ready for the shelves.
Her fragrance collection changes with the seasons. Autumn favorites include Pumpkin Pie, Caramel Apple, Snickerdoodle Cookie, Pumpkin Patchouli, and Cinnamon Chai.
As the holidays approach, customers can also look for winter scents such as Balsam Fir, Bayberry Cypress, Cranberry Apple, Juniper Pine, Chocolate Fudge, and Gingerbread House.

More Than Candles
While candles are at the heart of the business, there’s much more to browse at Wishing Well.
Natalie has expanded her fragrance collection to include wax melts, room and linen sprays, reed diffusers, car diffusers, and other options for enjoying the same scents throughout the home.
The shop also carries handmade gifts from Lancaster County artists and makers, including jewelry, soaps, pottery, crocheted items, and more.
One unexpected bestseller for Natalie has been the tea and honey collection, featuring loose-leaf teas, character tea infusers, and local honey.
Natalie is particularly proud of the shop’s dedicated men’s gift section, which includes wallets, grooming products, jewelry, multi-tools, and other items that can sometimes be harder to find in smaller gift shops.
And her love of animals has found a place in the business, too. Wishing Well donates 25% of sales from its pet section to Pet Pantry of Lancaster County and the Lancaster SPCA.

Make Your Own Candle
One of Natalie’s favorite parts of owning Wishing Well is getting to share what she’s learned.
She originally hoped to become an art teacher, so hosting candle-making classes gives her the chance to combine two things she loves: creating and teaching.
During these hands-on classes, participants can mix and match fragrances to create their own candles while learning more about the process. Classes are available by appointment at the Bricker Village shop.
Interested in joining a class? Visit Wishing Well Candles & Gifts to learn more and register.
Natalie also encourages customers to bring back their empty Wishing Well candle jars. She cleans and reuses the jars, helping reduce waste while giving customers 20% off their next candle purchase of the same size for each eligible jar returned.
The shop also offers a loyalty punch card program. Customers receive a stamp with each purchase, and their sixth purchase earns them a free candle.
Come Say Hello at Bricker Village
For Natalie, one of the best parts of having a shop at Bricker Village is the people. From the friendships she’s built with neighboring business owners to the customers who stop in, she appreciates the community that surrounds Wishing Well.
When someone walks into Wishing Well, she hopes they’ll feel right at home, surrounded by familiar scents, handmade goods, and a friendly face.
The next time you’re visiting Bricker Village, stop by Wishing Well to meet Natalie, browse the collection, and see what she’s been creating.



